Clare L. Deming

I read Dawn by Octavia E. Butler for a book club discussion at the end of 2024. I had too many physical books that I needed to read, so I listened to this one as an audiobook, narrated by Julienne Irons. Dawn is the first book in the Xenogenesis or Lilith’s Brood series (paid links).

I previously read Parable of the Sower by this same author (paid link) and you can find my review of it here.

Here is the blurb:

When Lilith lyapo wakes from a centuries-long sleep, she finds herself aboard the vast spaceship of the Oankali. She discovers that the Oankali—a seemingly benevolent alien race—intervened in the fate of the humanity hundreds of years ago, saving everyone who survived a nuclear war from a dying, ruined Earth and then putting them into a deep sleep. After learning all they could about Earth and its beings, the Oankali healed the planet, cured cancer, increased human strength, and they now want Lilith to lead her people back to Earth—but salvation comes at a price.

Hopeful and thought-provoking, this post-apocalyptic narrative deftly explores gender and race through the eyes of characters struggling to adapt during a pivotal time of crisis and change.

I have so many thoughts about this book! It made for a great discussion with the book club. This is a hard book to say that I enjoyed because it was quite an uncomfortable read. The Oankali claim to care for the humans that they saved and to have our best interests in mind. But Lilith discovers that if she disagrees with the aliens, they can never accept her arguments and will keep gaslighting her and manipulating her until she is ultimately forced to agree with their decisions. All of her agency is an illusion. Yet at the same time, how much does she owe on behalf of humanity to the aliens who saved our species and our planet from our own destruction?

This book also deals with the topic of sexual consent quite a lot for being first published in 1987. The aliens claim that their species needs to exchange genetic information with each new species that they encounter as they travel through the galaxy. This means that they ask Lilith to have a part-human, part-Oankali baby as part of their conditions for returning the surviving humans to Earth. The aliens also act as match makers, trying to set her up with different men, oblivious to her own choice in this. If the price of mankind’s survival is to interbreed with aliens, then is our species truly surviving?

I loved how Lilith becomes an unreliable narrator to the other humans when they awaken. Her initial doubts about the aliens are duplicated by the other humans and she is self-aware enough to realize how she must sound to them, but cannot convince them that she isn’t under the control of the Oankali (because she is, even if she tries not to be). The factions that developed between the different people and how the group acted when placed into this situation was fascinating.

I thought that some of the science ideas in this book were also novel. One example was that the Oankali are fascinated with cancer and how it allows cells to proliferate. They cure Lilith of a tumor she didn’t know that she had, as well as eliminate her genetic predisposition to cancer. They use cancer as inspiration for their own medical advances.

This story continues in two more books, Adulthood Rites (#2) and Imago (#3), and I plan to read those later this year (paid links). Have you read anything by Octavia E. Butler? Let me know in the comments!

Find more of my reviews here.