Clare L. Deming

I didn’t realize that Charlie Jane Anders had a new book out until I came across it while browsing NetGalley. I’d really enjoyed three of her earlier books, and you can find my reviews as well as purchase links below. Lessons in Magic and Disaster is her newest book and my review follows.

• All the Birds in the Sky (review here / purchase here)
• The City in the Middle of the Night (review here / purchase here)
• Never Say You Can’t Survive (review here / purchase here)

Thank you to NetGalley and Tor Books for a copy in exchange for an honest review.

Here is the blurb:

In the vein of Alice Hoffman and Charlie Jane Anders’s own All the Birds in the Sky comes a novel full of love, disaster, and magic.

A young witch teaches her mother how to do magic–with very unexpected results–in this relatable, resonant novel about family, identity, and the power of love.

Jamie is basically your average New England academic in-training–she has a strong queer relationship, an esoteric dissertation proposal, and inherited generational trauma. But she has one extraordinary secret: she’s also a powerful witch.

Serena, Jamie’s mother, has been hiding from the world in an old one-room schoolhouse for several years, grieving the death of her wife and the simultaneous explosion in her professional life. All she has left are memories.

Jamie’s busy digging into a three-hundred-year-old magical book, but she still finds time to teach Serena to cast spells and help her come out of her shell. But Jamie doesn’t know the whole story of what happened to her mom years ago, and those secrets are leading Serena down a destructive path.

Now it’s up to this grad student and literature nerd to understand the secrets behind this mysterious novel from 1749, unearth a long-buried scandal hinted therein, and learn the true nature of magic, before her mother ruins both of their lives.

This book was one of a few unfortunate DNFs (did-not-finish) for me in 2025. I made it about a third of the way before I gave up. It wasn’t that it was bad, it just wasn’t for me, and I think there are probably people out there that will love this novel. Let me see if I can explain my reaction.

Jamie is the protagonist and discovers that she can perform rites that cause favorable events to happen for her. This magic has no instructions or teacher, but she has fumbled her way to a rudimentary functional understanding that allows her to produce vaguely predictable results. I found the initial descriptions of the magic to be inventive and in a way, earnest. I could truly believe that this magic worked for Jamie and her mother, and that drew me in at the beginning of this book.

However, the story became less about the magic and more about Jamie’s relationships and her thesis struggles. By itself, those ideas could make for a decent story, but I never liked Jamie and couldn’t get invested in her struggles. Much of the novel is taken over by her obsessive research into a mid-18th century novel that feels like it should exist, but doesn’t. I felt like I was not enough of a literature nerd to understand what was going on, and this aspect of the story bored me.

I think that the concept (for as far as I got) would have worked better in a shorter format. Despite not enjoying this book, I loved the author’s earlier books and would still pick up a future novel by her.

Have you read anything by Charlie Jane Anders? Which book was your favorite? Let me know in the comments.

You can find more of my book reviews here.