Clare L. Deming

The Book That Wouldn’t Burn by Mark Lawrence was an impulse buy for me earlier in 2024. I had read one of this author’s earlier novels (Prince of Thorns) and hated it so much that I declined to review it (this was for another site). But Mark Lawrence has since built himself a reputation as a leading author in the grimdark genre so I thought I’d give him another try with this novel, the first in The Library Trilogy (paid links).

Here is the blurb:

The boy has lived his whole life trapped within a book-choked chamber older than empires and larger than cities.

The girl has been plucked from the outskirts of civilization to be trained as a librarian, studying the mysteries of the great library at the heart of her kingdom.

They were never supposed to meet. But in the library, they did.

Their stories spiral around each other, across worlds and time. This is a tale of truth and lies and hearts, and the blurring of one into another. A journey on which knowledge erodes certainty and on which, though the pen may be mightier than the sword, blood will be spilled and cities burned.

I loved this book so much, so Mark Lawrence has hereby redeemed himself as an author for me. This novel follows two point-of-view characters – Livira and Evar. Each suffers tragedy and earns instant sympathy from the reader. Livira’s plight is more immediate when she is kidnapped from her settlement by sabbers, then rescued by a patrol and taken to the nearby city where she bluffs her way into a position as a trainee librarian.

Evar is trapped in an eternal library with his small family of others who share a similar fate. The circumstances that brought him to this situation are mysterious, but he is determined to escape.

The library in this book is nearly a character itself and is ancient, inscrutable, and possibly infinite. No one knows who created it or how it has continued to exist through cycles of war and devastation. Only a fraction of the rooms have been catalogued, some are completely inaccessible, and guides are rare and only appear to those specially chosen. This story is partly a love letter to reading, books, and libraries, and here is one quote that I particularly liked from this book:

“That’s all anyone ever is–the story they tell, and the stories told about them. Fiction captures more than facts do. That’s why the library keeps it. It’s the most important part of our memories.”

I loved the worldbuilding in this story. The mythology of the library and the religion behind it echoed our own world and then diverged into its own fascinating struggle between good and evil. Outside the library, we have a sense that there is a cycle of war between the humans and the sabbers, but also hints of other dangers driving this central conflict.

This story also hints at a multiverse of sorts. Both Evar and Livira find their way to The Exchange, a place that reminded me of The Wood Between the Worlds from C.S. Lewis’ Narnia book, The Magician’s Nephew (paid link). This wood is filled with pools that function as gates to other timelines and parallel worlds. This place becomes central to the story as it is the only way that Evar and Livira can meet.

About three quarters of the way through the book, a massive twist is revealed. It made me question everything I had already read! From there, chaos and action drove the last quarter of the book to an ending that was both heartbreaking and satisfying. I can’t wait to read the next book in the series, The Book That Broke the World. I have already pre-ordered the final book in the series, The Book That Held Her Heart, that will be released April 8, 2025 (paid links).

Have you read any books by Mark Lawrence? Which ones did you enjoy? Let me know in the comments!

You can find more of my book reviews here.